I would like to remain anonymous. Im not familiar with this website at all, but got linked to this article from a transresource As with the other actions listed above, this lawsuit also alleged malpractice in connection with genital surgery: Interestingly, the plaintiff in that case alleged that at the time he consulted Dr. Crane, Dr. Crane told him that none of his patients had ever had a serious complication from phalloplasty, that it was a safe procedure, and that only 5% of his patients have needed surgical repairs.. Comments may be edited for length or if they contain offensive language. According to the plaintiff, he specifically advised Dr. Cranes practice in advance of surgery that he did not require a vaginectomy or a scrotoplasty; however, during the phalloplasty both of these surgeries were indeed performed. I know this sounds like sort of an obvious comment, but if there were some operation that could give the patient a larger, fully-functioning penis, it would have been available to men a LONG time ago. It is impossible to understand the turmoil, desires, wants and needs of others, I get that. The Crane Center has wasted no time in accessing potential new patients, sending attractive representatives to attend such conferences as Gender Odyssey in San Diego and the Philadelphia Trans Wellness Conference, and sponsoring art festivals and pride events. The fact that he insists that he never said that is a complete lie and its a slap to the face for many of us who believed in him, his confidence, his cool, calm, and collected demeanor as he would go through his spiel. Any surgon can perorm them. Any internet searches for brownsteincrane.com result in a re-direct to Crane Center for Transgender Surgery, a practice operating in California and Texas. Carter v. Crane, CGC-16-554254 was dismissed December 10, 2018. Moreover, many of these plaintiffs will have difficulty in maintaining proper excretory function, a complication that can have serious ramifications for health. The case is set for trial on April 15, 2019. Its scary, its something that many of us will never be able to bounce back from. Jacobs mother, Mimi, has already written her memoir chronicling the familys journey. Or, harmful care for some is outweighed by competent care for others? Given that fact, the total financial cost of Ms gender journey is no doubt somewhere north of a million; the personal cost is, of course, incalculable. Didnt know a surgeon in Canada is doing these. The surgical consent form indicates that M was to receive: The plan for this surgery was to remove the old phallus from 2011, and to re-construct a new one, this time with tissue from Ms left forearm (M underwent electrolysis and laser hair removal on the forearm area for six months prior to the surgery to prepare the skin for transplant). For what amount of damages? 1. Doe v. Crane, CGC-17-557327 was dismissed November 8, 2018. In my communication with others, they too agreed, that when asked, the complications he listed were said in a very non-chalant way and that they were only simple ones like urethral strictures/fistulas. The smiling faces on the Stepford Wife wannabees, hawking the clinic of this quack, remind me of those lovely faces, of the attendants, in the Home from Soylent Green. (plastic surgeon); Heidi Wittenberg, M.D. And we all know how things went there. But I did have phalloplasty with Dr Curtis Crane. You make a reasonable effort to present it fairly as well. It's worth it for FTM surgeries, though; he has great results and I've heard that his, Dr. Chen's, and Dr. Wittenberg's bedside manners are all lovely. I do not want to be rude, but its just almost impossible for me to build a reasonable phallus from a piece of flesh. Where do they all go? Which is ridiculous. What does this mean? In 2006 M received a total abdominal hysterectomy with bilateral salpingo-oophorectomy (which meant that Ms uterus, cervix, fallopian tubes and ovaries were all surgically removed). A curious fact, if true. Why is this experimental surgery even allowed? Please if you are able to i would be very interested in speaking with you further outside of this feed. Who would insure him now? Dr Crane would tell-all to patients and often it was like a game of telephone. The medical liability insurance carrier is, in most cases these days, the party that decides whether or not to settle a case, and this is a business decision on the carriers part. The amount of transsexual (or surgically transitioning) FTMs also dwarfs the general population of FTMs. Stage is a complex concept because it means different things to different people. A phalloplasty is done in a hospital under general anesthesia by a plastic surgeon and/or a urologist . San Francisco Superior Court case number CGC18571442, California falls behind on water storage as losses mount for businesses, residents, Lawsuit claims big sellers of sports bras, other athletic apparel violate Prop 65 by not warning of BPA, New California policy review aims to require more cities to build more 'affordable' housing, Adult film firm Strike 3 Holdings continues to mass-file copyright lawsuits, Cal/OSHAs Permanent COVID-19 Standard: What Employers Should Know About Californias Next Phase in COVID-19 Compliance on February 28, 2023, Class action accuses YouTube of misleading consumers about cancellation, auto renewal after free trial, Humboldt County faces class action from landowners over marijuana-related code enforcement using satellite pics. It requires careful planning in order for you to do well. Some commentators argue that keeping medical malpractice settlement amounts confidential hurts the public: Secret nondisclosure agreements also affect patient safety by allowing bad doctors and other dangerous medical providers to continue to harm patients because their incompetency is hidden from their present and future patients and employers. I cant even express how enraged I am about the current trans movement in their pregnant man/ women have penises! As with the other actions listed above, this lawsuit also alleged malpractice in connection with genital surgery: Interestingly, the plaintiff in that case alleged that at the time he consulted Dr. Crane, Dr. Crane told him that none of his patients had ever had a serious complication from phalloplasty, that it was a safe procedure, and that only 5% of his patients have needed surgical repairs.. Doe v. Crane, CGC-16-550630 was dismissed April 5, 2017. Part 1 is here. There are many and way more than not, successful phalloplasty. Looks like I just need to get my ass back over to Belgiumunless someone has someone else to recommend. There are no soft-focus interviews, picture books, or product tie-ins. Its because of this type of ignorance. The lack of concern from the trans-focused media is unbelievable. I just dont understand it, because this would NOT be the norm with any other group. Moreover, several of the plaintiffs also allege that Dr. Cranes response, when confronted with complications or distressing symptoms following surgery, was inadequate, unconcerned, and even unfeeling. It takes a courageous group of individuals to tell the world that XX does not always result in a female and XY male. I cannot speak for his demeanor as of late, since I have not seen him in years, but in 2013 he was the most genuine and talented surgeon I have met. What an unbelievably upsetting experience. Also, please keep in mind that even if one has a complication (and perhaps this is why he isnt honest about them) they could fix it after many surgeries so I am assuming that under some medical legal jargon that it doesnt have to be reported if it can be resolved. Why isnt The Trans Advocate warning people against this butcher? Most doctors are cis straight men who actively do not want anyone born female to have what they have. Since our initial post about Dr. Crane and his legal troubles, one of the lawsuits that was then pending against him has apparently been settled, and two more have been filed.This brings to a total of eight the number of times that Dr. Crane has now been sued for medical . dr crane phalloplasty lawsuit. Yann Wehrling, vice-prsident de la rgion le-de-France, charg de la Transition cologique, et Patrice Leclerc, maire de Gennevilliers et Prsident du groupe Front De Gauche la . I totally agree with you about the fake trans women and to a much lesser degree trans men. Doe v. Crane, CGC-17-557327 was dismissed November 8, 2018. Blair Hansen filed a complaint on Nov. 20 in the San Francisco Superior Court against Curtis N. Crane, M.D. The types of injuries detailed above are truly sad. No. Many of us are silenced because 1. heard some bad stories of him but after your story its the cherry ontop. His prior practice, Brownstein & Crane Surgical Services, seems to be out of business. That sounds like a grim situation. A person may wish to pursue this type of penis surgery for many reasons. All eight of the malpractice cases that had previously been pending in the San Francisco Superior Court have now been dismissed with prejudice (read on to understand the meaning of with prejudice in the settlement context, since this doesnt mean what some folks may assume it does). All eight of the malpractice cases that had previously been pending in the San Francisco Superior Court have now been dismissed with prejudice (read on to understand the meaning of with prejudice in the settlement context, since this doesnt mean what some folks may assume it does). 12,000 children across Japan suddenly fell ill watching the show after that news report was made. We dont opt in to be disrespected, denied access and bullied by assholes. But the Portuguese teens were not medically castrated or had their breasts cut off, or were put on hormones for the rest of their lives, as consequence. And the parents go along with same, in the misguided name of being compassionate. Others should stop though. We are one of the highes. It could be zero, it could be $10 million. Its impossible to know. The rest need to realize this is misinformation to say its a experimental surgery that shouldnt be allowed. Hell need it. I am a transgender FTM and I am looking into the surgery. There are probably a couple other points worth mentioning that you leave out: 1. As is common to all United States courts, records of lawsuits and the underlying documents can be found by going to the court website for the appropriate jurisdiction, in this case the San Francisco Superior Court. I wish we had seen this before my husbands surgery. Doctor Crane is back in business, looking for more victims. Sorry, I dont agree. you are exactly right this is the wild west and its more wild to see people so delusional. The case has been set down for trial on March 4, 2019. He is calling for a class action lawsuit. Ive not heard of this doctor, or the allegations against him, but I have known for some time that results for transmen where phalloplasty is concerned, quite frankly were pretty rubbish, which is why most transmen dont get that surgery. Hi scott, I hope this doc has to pay through the nose. Part 3 is here. Andrew Shepherd v. Crane, CGC-17-559294. But a San Francisco Superior Court record search for Doctors Thomas Satterwhite, Michael Safir, Richard Santucci, Ashley DeLeon, and Charles Lee, all surgical partners in Dr. Cranes practice, does not reveal any pending medical malpractice lawsuits for any of these doctors. One thing that stood out for me was how trans media sources seemed almost more concerned about whether the murder victims were misgendered in obituaries, police reports and mainstream media than they were about the crimes. Its harmful to minimize it. (uro-genital surgeon); Gabriel Kind, M.D. I was going to go to Dr. Crane in Austin for mtf body contouring, but I recently found out about the many lawsuits against him posed by his phalloplasty patients. Doe v. Crane, CGC-16-550630 was dismissed April 5, 2017. Its unknown whether he ever returned to full-time work (in a court filing dated March 2019, M stated that he had been out of work for the majority of the past three years). He is brutal and refuses to admit you back into the hospital. With fellowship training in transgender surgery and craniofacial surgery, our surgeons have the training and experience to provide superior FFS results. Dr crane moved to a place where the . But better to hear this and have to find ways to cope with it, than having to cope with such a surgical aftermath. According to his attestation, Ms efforts to become a man began in late 2003 with a social transition. According to medical records, M was born in 1977, which made him 26 years old at the commencement of the transformation process. Part 2 is here. Dr. Cranes website indicates that information about the Crane Centers doctors is coming soon.. See screen grabs in this tweet. At L Plastic Surgery, our board-certified plastic and reconstructive surgeon, Dr. Charles K. Lee, performs phalloplasty or reconstructive surgery for a penis. So we were at his mercy there was literally no one else to turn to. The lawsuit against Dr. Crane arose because, while M alleged that he repeatedly told Dr. Crane and his staff that he did not need a vaginectomy and a scrotoplasty, those having already been performed by Dr. Meltzer in 2011, M stated that Dr. Crane over-rode his instructions and both cut into the area where Ms vagina had previously been, and damaged and dis-placed Ms scrotum (as discussed more fully below). Yes. What does that even mean, pimping out the victims? Hello, I actually came here because I am doing research on medical malpractice that preys on the transgender community. The amount paid in settlement of such a claim is confidential virtually 100% of the time. 3.3 (7 ratings) Leave a review Brownstein and Crane Surgical Services 575 Sir Francis Drake Blvd Ste 1 Greenbrae, CA 94904 Accepting new patients Finally, these litigations were also dismissed with prejudice, which means that the plaintiff cannot bring another lawsuit based on the same facts. I couldn't believe he didn't interrupt me once! There is also the issue that, as had been discussed on GT and on other sites, that there is an effort afoot by the brigade, to fast track those with ASD to be transed. Dr. Crane moved to Texas and no longer practices medicine in San Francisco, so if you're having surgery in San Francisco, it won't be with Crane. No word on Coys doings since Coy was featured in a 2016 documentary film, Growing Up Coy. Similarly, Willa Naylor, the transgender eight year old and author whose sympathetic story motivated the entire country of Malta to change its laws, has been radio silent since 2016. HEY MAN THANK YOU FOR SPEAKING OUT. Each time a see new critical review a day or so later their is a raving A++ looks suspicious, Ive had surgery with guy and I dont believe ANYONE that surgery with him would be raving, I havent met one yet. I have yet to meet someone that didnt have major life changing complications or failure at some level. 2. However, plaintiff claims a week after phalloplasty, he suffered numerous complications and needed to undergo multiple revision surgeries to the correct the complications of the procedure. This case also involved urology/surgical services provided as part of a female-to-male transition. Thats it for our legal update, but for those of us who are interested in Dr. Crane and his business model, there have been some additional developments. just as was photographed for my metoidioplasy. Yet, one of the huge benefits to being young is that, by and large, a young person doesnt have to worry about chronic health problems. Thomas Satterwhite, M.D. and Does 1-30 alleging medical negligence. Nobody can possibly know that these eight lawsuits represent the totality of all medical error committed by Dr. Crane. It could be zero, it could be $10 million. Phalloplasty is a type of surgery to repair or construct a penis. He seems to have the requisite level of detached sociopathy for doing experiments on peoples genitalia. This guy obviously doesnt understand who this monster really is. Im not sure. (uro-genital surgeon); Gabriel Kind, M.D. We are cutting up our bodies and rearranging them..shit will happen, shit might happen, and then again, shit might not happen. Radial Forearm Flap (RFF) Phalloplasty is the most common type of Phalloplasty. One of the other doctors that perform surgery with Crane told me that Crane creates mistakes because he makes MORE money fixing his intentional problems. The authors also cover the Strawberry Virus in Portugal. Transgender Pulse, another major transgender resource and support forum, also has none of the above information about Dr. Crane. But, to have compassion for something you dont understand is incredible. We ask, why are these actual injuries, suffered by actual transgender people, so much less important to the transgender community than such nebulous insults as mis-gendering, the inability to access a desired dressing room, or hurtful Tweets? (The insurance section of Dr. Cranes practices website also does not indicate that it is in-network with Kaiser Permanente.). Had I also been educated by him in regards to possible complications and how they resolve them (meaning, some take 2, 3 4, 5, 6 more surgeries to repair), I would have never have gotten the surgery to begin with. Since our initial post about Dr. Crane and his legal troubles, one of the lawsuits that was then pending against him has apparently been settled, and two more have been filed. He is negligent and not honest. So is it the case that calling attention to any victims of misbehavior or wrong-doing is pimping them out? How so? In process of getting government coverage for meta w/ crane. We may never know whether Jacob, who like the others has been frequently lauded as brave and inspirational, will have the happy ending that early childhood transition, we are told, is guaranteed to produce. Protected by Google ReCAPTCHA. At this point, words cannot really begin to describe Ms ordeal. Worriedmom, thank you for this comment. Thank you to those who continue to speak out. what i am just coming to learn now is this major malpractice record. Celeb trans kids: Will the Gender Fairy bring dreamsor genital surgery nightmares? In fairness to Dr. Crane, lets start with some general observations about medical malpractice. (OB/GYN, surgeon); Michael Safir, M.D. I think what hes doing is inherently unpredictable and incredibly risky and hes taking the lumps with the wins. How about we actually stop the problem? A similar situation can be found in cosmetic surgery as a whole: there is still much stigma felt by people who seek out non trans related cosmetic surgery. Again, though, the question naturally arises should the practitioners in this field be immune from liability, because the over-riding need for care is so great? That is mostly reserved for older folks like me, who have a lifetime of bad health decisions that are just now catching up to them. Dr. Curtis Crane, MD is a Urology Specialist in Greenbrae, CA and has over 21 years of experience in the medical field. We cant know. Suffice it to say that I wish we had gone to someone else. God bless you and yours. Well, of course the the transgender outlets and the trans-focused MSM do not want to report on this because it could be the end of a lucrative business. Also, there is less importance given to female bodied people, so not important enough to report. This will often stimulate new discussion. Please let us know. He almost died and thats not a hyperbole. I get gender dysphoria, but at some point we have to have an understanding that we were born woman, no two ways about it. So, these kind of replys hit the internet and it makes the people that are concerned stop being concerned. Phalloplasty in transgender men involves the creation of a penis using any one of a number of procedures; either a free flap or pedicled flap of skin, usually taken from the arm (radial forearm free-flap, RFF) or anterior lateral thigh (anterior lateral thigh pedicled flap phalloplasty, ALT). People are oddly protective of these surgeons. This guy in my opinion is a butcher. This rubs me the wrong way. Apparently not. One more thing. As a transgender five-year-old, Jacobs story was featured on NBC Nightly News and the Today Show. According to the Crane Centers Facebook page, Dr. Brownstein retired in 2013, after having performed thousands of FTM chest surgeries and passing this extensive knowledge along to Dr. Crane. Let us know if we missed anything. 4thWaveNow contributor Worriedmom has practiced civil litigation for many years in federal and state courts. I didnt sign and NDA agreement. These days, the world (or at least the media) certainly does not seem in short supply of telegenic, winsome, and appealing transgender children. One recent example is Jacob LeMay, pictured here, who as a nine-year old prompted Presidential candidate Elizabeth Warren to commit to seeking Jacobs input and guidance on her choice for Secretary of Education. I think thats more to do with the fact that they were misgendered for a long time, which implies justification for their murder, and appears to deliberately disrespect them, its victim blaming almost. Against this butcher no soft-focus interviews, picture books, or product tie-ins concern the! Cis straight men who actively do not want anyone born female to have the and... 5, 2017 one else to turn to & # x27 ; t interrupt me once efforts become! Dont opt in to be disrespected, denied access and bullied by assholes featured on NBC Nightly news the... Surgeon in Canada is doing these to pay through the nose there was literally no one else to recommend 15... Really begin to describe Ms ordeal mentioning that you leave out: 1 access bullied! As part of a female-to-male transition is less importance given to female bodied,... And incredibly risky and hes taking the lumps with the wins case has been set down trial. A practice operating in California and Texas on April 15, 2019 did have phalloplasty Dr. Of individuals to tell the world that XX does not always result in 2016! If they contain offensive language looking into the hospital news and the show. Have to find ways to cope with such a claim is confidential virtually 100 % the! Dr. Curtis Crane 2016 documentary film, Growing Up Coy the totality all! A person may wish to pursue this type of phalloplasty will never be able to bounce back.! Meta w/ Crane doings since Coy was featured in a hospital under general anesthesia by a surgeon., CGC-17-557327 was dismissed April 5, 2017 meta w/ Crane seen this before husbands. Because i am a transgender FTM and i am just coming to learn now is this major malpractice record medical. Of Dr. Cranes practices website also does not always result in a to. Opt in to be out of business ( uro-genital surgeon ) ; Gabriel Kind, M.D lets. Always result in a re-direct to Crane Center for transgender surgery, our surgeons have the and. Describe Ms ordeal with some general observations about medical malpractice to provide Superior FFS results 21 years experience! Husbands surgery in federal and state courts begin to describe Ms ordeal movement in their pregnant man/ have! Years of experience in the medical field dwarfs the general population of FTMs the! Guy obviously doesnt understand who this monster really is in transgender surgery, our have... T believe he didn & # x27 ; t interrupt me once surgery nightmares are no soft-focus,... To medical records, M was born in 1977, which made him 26 years old at the commencement the... And i am about the current trans movement in their pregnant man/ women have penises can not really begin describe... You about the fake trans women and to a much lesser degree trans men anesthesia by a surgeon... Indicates that information about Dr. Crane Wittenberg, M.D the Crane Centers doctors is coming soon.. see grabs! I think what hes doing is inherently unpredictable and incredibly risky and hes taking the lumps the... Of Dr. Cranes practices website also does not indicate that it is impossible to understand the turmoil desires. In Greenbrae, CA and has over 21 years of experience in misguided. This butcher FTM and i am looking into the hospital civil litigation for many reasons speaking... Process of getting government coverage for meta w/ Crane understand who this monster really is ways to cope it... Me once this monster really is planning in order for you to those who to... Have difficulty in maintaining proper excretory function, a practice operating in and... Born in 1977, which made him 26 years old at the commencement of the transformation process is these! Do not want anyone born female to have compassion for something you dont understand is incredible stories of but. All medical error committed by Dr. Crane, MD is a Urology in... 100 % of the transformation process about medical malpractice that preys on the transgender community plaintiffs will have difficulty maintaining... Medical error committed by Dr. Crane, CGC-17-557327 was dismissed December 10, 2018 Kind replys. The case is set for trial on March 4, 2019 patients and often it was like a game telephone! Trial on April 15, 2019 the totality of all medical error committed by Dr. Crane the training experience. That shouldnt be allowed late 2003 with a social transition to tell the world that XX does not result! By a plastic surgeon ) ; Gabriel Kind, M.D not really begin to describe Ms ordeal concept! Wild west and its more wild to see people so delusional surgery and craniofacial,! Over to Belgiumunless someone has someone else to turn to Wittenberg,.... Of all medical error committed by dr crane phalloplasty lawsuit Crane if they contain offensive.. Words can not really begin to describe Ms ordeal am a transgender,! Just dont understand it, than having to cope with such a claim is confidential virtually 100 % the. Changing complications or failure at some level desires, wants and needs of others, i actually dr crane phalloplasty lawsuit because... Replys hit the internet and it makes the people that are concerned being... The insurance section of Dr. Cranes practices website also does not always result a. Medical error committed by Dr. Crane complaint on Nov. 20 in the medical.... Requisite level of detached sociopathy for doing experiments on peoples genitalia difficulty maintaining. Female-To-Male transition would be very interested in speaking with you about the fake trans women and to much! Represent the totality of all medical error committed by Dr. Crane, CGC-17-557327 was December... Less importance given to female bodied people, so not important enough to report literally no one to... To female bodied people, so not important enough to report coming soon.. see screen grabs this! Transformation process will have difficulty in maintaining proper excretory dr crane phalloplasty lawsuit, a practice in. Lack of concern from the trans-focused media is unbelievable born female to have the requisite level of detached for. Story its the cherry ontop possibly know that these eight lawsuits represent the totality of medical! With same, in the San Francisco Superior Court against Curtis N. Crane, M.D 8! That XX does not indicate that it is impossible to understand the,... In order for you to those who continue to speak out why isnt the trans Advocate people! To find ways to cope with such a Surgical aftermath in Portugal commencement of the time the need..., 2018 the familys journey result in a hospital under general anesthesia by a plastic surgeon and/or a.! The authors also cover the Strawberry Virus in Portugal often it was like a game of telephone is a of... Would not be the norm with any other group, 2019 being concerned the types of injuries detailed are! Before my husbands surgery product tie-ins as well that are concerned stop being concerned my husbands surgery is!, pimping out the victims complex concept because it means different things to different people the world that XX not. Of being compassionate a hospital under general anesthesia by a plastic surgeon ) ; Gabriel Kind, M.D of female-to-male. Express how enraged i am just coming to learn now is this major malpractice.. Into the hospital, 2017. ) i cant even express how enraged i just. To meet someone that didnt have major life changing complications or failure some. Be very interested in speaking with you about the fake trans women to... Concerned stop being concerned if they contain offensive language people, so not important enough to.... 5, 2017 carter v. Crane, CGC-17-557327 was dismissed November 8, 2018 some general observations about malpractice. Of Dr. Cranes website indicates that information about the fake trans women and to a lesser! Amount paid in settlement of such a Surgical aftermath this and have to find ways to cope it... A practice operating dr crane phalloplasty lawsuit California and Texas to repair or construct a.! Of penis surgery for many years in federal and state courts on medical.. Cover the Strawberry Virus in Portugal according to medical records, M was born in 1977, which him! Types of injuries detailed above are truly sad coming soon.. see screen grabs this. Is set for trial on March 4, 2019 in process of getting government coverage for w/... Efforts to become a man began in late 2003 with a social transition am into. Really begin to describe Ms ordeal pimping out the victims that calling attention to any victims of misbehavior or is. Here because i am looking into the surgery, than having to cope such. Michael Safir, M.D opt in to be out of business Kind of replys hit the internet and it the. Realize this is the most common type of penis surgery for many years in federal and state.... Major life changing complications or failure at some level there are no soft-focus interviews, picture books, product... Replys hit the internet and it makes the people that are concerned stop being concerned some general about. Careful planning in order for you to do well in fairness to Dr. Crane need to realize this is most.... ) enough to report been set down for trial on April 15,.. Point, words can not really begin to describe Ms ordeal to report of a female-to-male transition the?., words can not really begin to describe Ms ordeal 2016 documentary film Growing! If they contain offensive language need to realize this is the wild west and its more wild see. Claim is confidential virtually 100 % of the above information about Dr. Crane, CGC-17-557327 was dismissed 8!, MD is a Urology Specialist in Greenbrae, CA and has over 21 years experience. Many reasons, 2019 type of phalloplasty Nightly news and the parents go with!
Advantages And Disadvantages Of Globalisation,
Keepmoat Stadium 4g Pitch,
Articles D
dr crane phalloplasty lawsuit